Skip to content

Breeder Wins Case Against State Veterinary Board



On July 15, 2004, Bonnie Cady, Tennessee Walking Horse breeder and trainer of The Horse Hub, Shelbyville, Tenn., was served with a court order for practicing veterinary medicine without a license. A breeder and trainer for over 20 years and graduate of Colorado State University’s breeding program, Cady has stood several stallions, collected semen, artificially inseminated, flushed, administered hormones and antibiotics to encourage inception and ultrasounded mares owned by her and other customers. All activities many consider "normal" for a breeding manager to practice.

However, according to Tennessee law the definition of practicing veterinary medicine includes "the use of any manual or mechanical procedure for artificial insemination, for testing for pregnancy, or for correcting sterility or infertility or to render advice or recommendation with regard to any of the above."

The Tennessee Board of Veterinary Medical Examiners ruled that Cady had engaged in the unlicensed practice of veterinary medicine and assessed a penalty of $17,000; $1,000 for each year Cady allegedly practiced unlicensed veterinary medicine.

Cady made an appeal in March 2005 to the Davidson County Chancery Court and petitioned the Board to determine the validity of the laws regarding licensed veterinary practice. The Court determined that the established laws, when incorporated verbatim, were "overbroad and thus, invalid." Since Cady had not diagnosed or treated an animal for disease or bodily injury and had not treated or diagnosed for sterility or infertility in an animal, the Court decided that inducing and confirming a pregnancy in an animal does not violated the laws of licensed veterinary practice.

At the end of 2007, the Court ruled in favor of Cady and the Legislature was amended so the "practice of veterinary medicine does not include artificial insemination of livestock, including horses. Such artificial insemination is now deemed an accepted livestock management practice."

More Stories

  • Unsung Heroes of the Industry

    Saddle Horse Report Salutes The Industry’s Unsung Heroes! Read More
  • ASHBA Select Series Improving and Expanding for 2021

    The ASHBA National Select Series, is expanding and improving for the 2021 show season! This program debuted to much excitement and success during a very challenging 2020 competition season. 1000 American Saddlebreds and members had an increased opportunity to compete for additional recognition and enjoyment last year. Read More
  • ASAC Honors 2020 Award Winners

    Out of an abundance of caution, the American Saddlebred Association of the Carolinas (ASAC) canceled its 42nd awards banquet and in-person general membership meeting scheduled for February 6, 2021. The annual membership meeting was held virtually and the following officers and board members were elected... Read More
  • American Saddlebred Museum Elects New Board of Trustees

    The American Saddlebred Museum was pleased to announce a new Board of Trustees during the Museum’s Annual Membership Meeting on Friday, February 19 via Zoom... Read More
  • TSHSA Announces 2021 Scholarship Recipients

    TriState Horse Shows Association is proud to announce the 2021 scholarship winners. The award honors excellence in academics, community involvement and participation in the show industry. Each winner was awarded a scholarship of $1250. Read More
  • Robertson Equine Spring Sale Changes Dates

    Dates have changed for the RES Spring Sale. Originally scheduled for Friday and Saturday, March 26-27th, the sale will now take place Wednesday and Thursday, June 9-10, during Rock Creek Horse Show held in Louisville.  Read More
  • River Ridge Closes

    It has been said that all good things must come to an end, and that has come true today... Read More
  • American Saddlebred Museum’s Ticket to Ride Raffle Drawing is March 15

    Time is running out to purchase a Ticket to Ride Raffle Ticket!  Purchase a $50 raffle ticket for a chance to win your Custom Ordered 2021 Ford Bronco Badlands with standard powertrain and standard equipment or $30,000 cash.   Read More
  • Amateur Exhibitor Auction and Competition Fundraiser

    The AHHS and AHHS National Futurity committee are organizing a fundraiser. The purpose of this fundraiser is to raise money for the Futurity, while creating a fun interactive way to include owners and trainers, encourage people to show, and create new interest in the Futurity. Read More
  • 2021 LBS Stallion List

    Members, the 2021 Limited Breeder’s Sweepstakes Stallion Service Auction is being held online this year.  We are excited to announce the online auction website will open for bids next week! Read More