Skip to content

Stallion Venture Withstands Tax Court Scrutiny



by John Alan Cohan, Attorney at Law
 
 
Sometimes the Tax Court can yield a surprising decision.  Tax Court judges are appointed the same way as all federal judges, by the President, and approved by the Senate.  The judges all have significant experience in tax law, but their reputations vary in terms of how sympathetic they are to arguments given on behalf of taxpayers.
 
In this case, the judge was sympathetic to a taxpayer who conducted a horse activity with no profits, but whose testimony was honest and sincere as to her efforts to make a profit despite the difficulties.
 
This case, Coldiron v. Commissioner [Docket No. 5180-125] involved Linda Coldiron, who worked part-time as a successful consultant.  Losses were about $562,000 over an eight-year period, and income was negligible.
 
The petitioner started with a young stallion with excellent bloodlines that petitioner thought she could promote at shows, and then breed.  Petitioner researched the profit-making potential of various horse breeds, and decided to purchase an Andalusian stallion with an impressive pedigree, for $12,500.  The horse was insured for $25,000.
 
She purchased a property in need of improvements, intending to use it in the horse activity, and constructed a residence, doing much of the work herself to avoid costs.
 
There was no formal business plan, but petitioner calculated costs and expenses, and anticipated that her property would increase in value.  She registered her business name, maintained a separate bank account, and had business cards and letterhead stationery.
 
She hired a professional trainer, and the stallion won championships.  An injury laid up the horse, and meanwhile petitioner developed promotional materials for use in marketing, including a website.  The horse was chosen to represent the Andalusian breed in a national advertising campaign.  Petitioner entered the horse into more shows, winning several titles.
 
The court concluded that Ms. Coldiron intended to make a profit, and allowed deduction of the tax losses.  The court said:  “It appears from the record that the efforts to promote Marciano as a top Andalusian stallion were successful in that his credentials were consistent with other top Andalusian stallions with demonstrated and successful stud careers.”
 
The court noted that petitioner applied her prior marketing experience in developing the income-producing capabilities of the stallion, she changed her operating methods to improve chances of making a profit, and she maintained complete and accurate books and records, including a summary for each year showing expenses broken down by categories.
 
This case shows that even if a horse activity focuses on one principal horse, the expenses may be justified from a tax standpoint so long as there is convincing evidence reflecting the taxpayer’s intentions.
 
Many judges will require more documentary evidence than shown in this case.  Lacking a formal business plan, Ms. Coldiron was able to overcome this obstacle by her own witness dynamics.  Apparently, the taxpayer was well-prepared, and her testimony was convincing.  Another element was that petitioner’s stallion in fact achieved recognition, and this was evidence that the petitioner could eventually make a profit in stud service and marketing of foals.
 
[John Alan Cohan is an attorney who serves the horse, livestock and farming industries.  He can be reached at:  (310) 278-0203, or email at johnalancohan@aol.com.  His website is JohnAlanCohan.com.]

More Stories

  • 2019 AHHS Showmanship Final

    The UPHA American Royal National Championship Horse Show and the American Hackney Horse Society are pleased to announce the AHHS Youth Medallion Showmanship In Hand Championship will be held at the 2019 UPHA American Royal.  Read More
  • Arrangements for Jeanette Durant

    A Midwest legend, Jeanette Durant passed away peacefully this morning (September 10) at the age of 89. She is reunited with her late husband of 50 years, Dick. Together, they were a great training team, known for so many world’s champion teams. Jeanette was known for being able to ride a gaited horse like few others! Read More
  • Bartz Impact Scholarship Award Nominations Open

    The American Saddlebred Museum is pleased to accept nominations for the Keith Bartz Impact Scholarship Award. The award is $1,500 and is given to an individual dedicated to raising awareness of the American Saddlebred and improving the community.   Read More
  • Route 66 Moves Dates and Welcomes Saddlebreds

    The show committee of the Route 66 Morgan Classic, held July 25-27 at the Tulsa Expo Center, arranged a meeting during the show to hear the voices of the trainers and exhibitors about what the show committee could do to make the show thrive... Read More
  • Calling Past Good Hands Champions

    The Good Hands National Finals and Mid-America Horse Show Association are looking for past Junior Exhibitor and Adult Good Hands Champions! We request your presence as the Finals celebrates its 90th Anniversary at the Mane Event Horse Show, which will be held in Springfield, Illinois from October 17-20, 2019. Read More
  • Board Unanimously Approves AMHA Relocation Proposal

    At the Third Quarter Board meeting held Saturday, September 7 in Las Vegas, Nevada, the American Morgan Horse Association’s Board of Directors unanimously approved the recommendation to relocate the AMHA home office... Read More
  • ASHA Funding Fall 2019 Business-Consulting Program for Saddlebred Businesses and Lesson Barns- Apply Today!

    The American Saddlebred Horse Association (ASHA) is thrilled to announce our partnership with equine industry leading business consultant Elisabeth McMillan of “Equestrian Professional.com, the Horse Business Site”... Read More
  • It takes a village...

    Read More
  • 2019 Alex Mooney Scholarship Winners Announced

    The Grand National World Championship Morgan Horse Show is pleased to congratulate Jessica Hyman of Fulton, New York and Linel Mullendore of Monroe, Washington, the winners of the 2019 Alex Mooney Scholarship.  Read More
  • World’s Championship Horse Show Wrap Up Issue

    SHR World’s Championship Horse Show wrap up issue is out today! It will be at All American and Summers End horse shows tomorrow and in the mail to subscribers across the nation! Read More