Skip to content

A Significant Victory in a New Tax Court Case



by John Alan Cohan, Attorney at Law  
 
A new Tax Court case involved several million dollars of losses from 2004-2009 in an Arabian horse farm owned by Henry and Christie Metz.  [Metz v. Commissioner, T.C. Memo. 2015-54.]
 
The Metzes specialize in Straight Eqyptians, and established their horse farm in 1991, at a time when prices of quality Arabians had dropped significantly from the 1980s.  The Metzes believed that prices had reached their bottom.

Mrs. Metz worked full-time on farm advertising, marketing and promotion, drawing on her fine-arts background.  In 1995 the taxpayers bought a farm in Naples, Florida for $550,000, and viewed this as an ideal location.  However, costs kept increasing and losses continued to mount.  They sold the Naples property for a profit and moved operations to Santa Ynez, California, with its large concentration of Arabian horse farms, and a steady flow of buyers.

Despite millions in losses, the Metzes remained optimistic about their farm’s future.  Since 2008 they had significantly reduced their expenses and increased revenue.  In 2011 they achieved a profit for the first six months by selling five horses at an average price of $70,000.

The judge, in analyzing the Metzes’ intent, made the following findings:

The Metzes kept records in a businesslike manner, using Quickbooks, and their CPA prepared monthly bank reconciliations, accounts-payable listings, and profit-and-loss statements.  They used an attorney’s prepared contracts for horse and semen sales.  Some sales contracts to foreign buyers were unsigned by the buyer, which led the IRS to argue that this “is not the kind of problem an intelligent businessperson would leave unaddressed.”  However, the judge found that especially with customers from a different culture, “pristine perfect preset paperwork” may not always accompany every business transaction.

The Metzes maintained potential customer lists, with records of contacts made with relevant details of their discussions; and sent out professional-quality promotional materials with copies of articles featuring the Metzes’ horse activity.

They had annual written business plans that included goals, job descriptions, policies and procedures, a description of each horse, and proposed advertising and promotion opportunities for the upcoming year.  The judge rejected the IRS’s argument that the plans lacked detailed information on methods to decrease costs or increase revenues, saying the IRS was attempting to substitute its own business judgment for the Metzes’.
There was extensive advertising and promotion, including ads in trade journals, and an attractive website.  The Metzes regularly reviewed analytics to track which pages were most often read as well as the location of visitors.  A high percentage of contacts came through the website.

There were dozens of horse sales between 2004 and 2009, including some for six figures, even up to $250,000.

The IRS argued that the Metzes failed to track expenses on a per-horse basis and that this was a clear indication their books and records fell short of businesslike standards.  In other words, the lack of individualized records shows a lack of profit motive.  The judge disagreed that a horse-by-horse breakdown is required to indicate a profit motive.

The judge found that the Metzes used their records to assess economic performance and identify cost-reducing strategies.  Their records were far more organized than others found to be adequate for section 183 purposes.

The judge found that the Metzes made changes in an effort to improve profits, most notably deciding against staying in Naples, Florida and relocating to Santa Ynez for the increased foot traffic and lower costs.  The Metzes also responded to the increasing interest in the Arabian horse market from the Middle East, networking at large shows in the Middle East.  The five horses they sold in 2011, at an average price of over $70,000 per horse, were all to foreigners.

Henry Metz was president of the Pyramid Society, a society dedicated to breeding Egyptian Arabians, and he was involved in the merger of AHRA with IAHA, and “was also recognized within the industry as a businessman who had the skills to turn around not just his own farm but a very troubled Arabian horse industry.”

The judge emphasized the importance of expertise of the taxpayer and consultants not only in animal husbandry, but in the economics of the activity, and concluded that the Metzes demonstrated expertise in the economics of the activity.

The judge noted that the Metzes devoted their full time to the activity, and that “their management and development of [the farm] has been aimed at breeding horses to sell, and they’ve worked personally and with great effort.”

The judge also concluded that the significant appreciation of the taxpayers’ assets -- the farm property, their horses and frozen semen -- suggested a profit motive along with the other evidence.

Finally, the judge held that the long history of losses was explainable as due to customary business risks and reverses; and some of the Metzes’ problems were industrywide.  The judge also rejected the IRS’s argument that the Metzes could never recoup their losses, stating that “if a taxpayer can expect to generate an overall profit from the current year onward, then it can’t be said that he lacks a profit objective simply because he will never generate an overall profit over the lifetime of the activity.”

This is an extremely important case, and will have long-range ramifications for horse owners as well as ranchers in the livestock industry.
 
[John Alan Cohan is an attorney who serves the horse, livestock and farming industries.  He can be reached at:  (310) 278-0203, or email at johnalancohan@aol.com.  His website is JohnAlanCohan.com.]
 

More Stories

  • **Updated Event Cancellations

    Saddle Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse events. Read More
  • A Blast From The Past

    Saddle Horse Report is pleased to bring you a series of past feature stories on some of the greats of our sport. Please enjoy this walk down memory lane. Read More
  • Future Forum: The Up and Coming of Young Trainers

    Enjoy the first in a series on young trainers! Read More
  • Class of 2020 Yearbook

    Saddle Horse Report presents the Class of 2020 Yearbook. We are proud to feature some of the 2020 graduates who are and will be a major force in the show horse industry. We know their talent and perseverance will help carry them on to many successes ahead. Read More
  • New England Morgan Horse Cancelled

    It is with very heavy hearts that the New England Show Committee along with the New England Morgan Horse Association decided to cancel the New England Morgan Horse Show July 20 – 25, 2020. Much of the decision making was taken out of our hands by the state of Massachusetts and the Department of Agriculture... Read More
  • Capital City Classic Coming to Raleigh

    The American Saddlebred Association of the Carolinas (ASAC) has sanctioned a new show on the 2020 calendar. The Capital City Classic will be held June 4-6th at the Governor James B. Hunt Horse Complex in Raleigh, North Carolina... Read More
  • Ten Years Ago - Greater Boston

    Greater Boston has become a Memorial Day tradition in New England. We miss being there this weekend, so let’s take a look back at some of our fond memories from 2010. Read More
  • Ten Years Ago - Michigan All-Morgan

    We wish our friends in Michigan well this Memorial Day weekend. While we won’t be able to spend our weekend with them, let’s take a look back at some of the highlights from the 2010 Michigan All-Morgan. Read More
  • Foals N Focus – Week 7

    Thank you to all who again submitted heart-warming shots of their 2020 foals for consideration in our ongoing #foalsNfocus contest. This week featured a photo of our first Half-Saddlebred winner, a colt sired by the Dutch Harness Horse, Graaf Kelly out of the American Saddlebred mare, WV Sinfully Irresistible... Read More
  • Ten Years Ago – Madison Classic

    We won’t have a chance to visit with our friends and enjoy Brat Fest this year in Madison. Let’s take a look back at happier times from the 2010 Madison Classic. Read More