Skip to content

How Would You Rank Conformational Faults - Expanded Poll Question

Posted February 7, 2002
Current USA Equestrian rules state that conformation accounts for 25% of American Saddlebred judging; in-hand classes specify 50%. However, little guidance is given as tot he relative importance of various conformational faults. These defects fall mainly into two categories: functional and aesthetic. Some functional faults will affect the horse's performance, therefore are more easily judged. Aesthetics are more a matter of opinion.

Because rules state that these and any other defects attributable to heredity must be penalized, a strong message is sent to American Saddlebred breeders as to what is or is not acceptable conformation.

Please consider how you would rank these faults from most penalized (1) to least penalized (9). Please email your comments prior to February 18, as we are providing the responses to the American Saddlebred Horse Association prior to their annual convention.

- Ideal: Well-shaped with large, wide-set, expressive eyes; gracefully shaped ears set close together on top of the head and carried alertly; a straight face line with a relatively fine muzzle and large nostrils, and a clean smooth jaw line
- Penalized: Lack of Saddlebred type, coarse or plain head, Roman nose, round jaws, lop ears, wide ears, small eyes

- Ideal: Long, arched and well flexed at the poll with a fine, clean throat latch
- Penalized: Short neck, straight neck, ewe neck, thick throat latch

- Ideal: Deep and sloping
- Penalized: Hollow chest, straight shoulders

- Ideal: Well defined and prominent
- Penalized: Flat withers

- Ideal: Strong and level, with well sprung ribs
- Penalized: Sway back, roached back

- Ideal: Level with a well-carried tail set on high
- Penalized: Crooked tail, low tail, unlevel

- Ideal: The front legs should be well forward, under the shoulder. The line of the hind leg, in a natural stance, should be vertical from the point of the buttock to the back edge of the cannon bone. The forearms and the hindquarters are well-muscled to the knees and hocks. Legs are straight with broad flat bones, sharply defined tendons and sloping pasterns.
- Penalized: Crooked legs, calved knees, over at the knee, bow legs, rough joints, round bones, straight pasterns, base stance too wide or too narrow, sickle hocks, cow hocks

- Ideal: Good and sound, open at the heel, neither toed in or toed out
- Penalized: Splay feet, pigeon toes, contracted heels

- Ideal: The ASB is well proportioned and presents a beautiful overall picture. The animal should be in good flesh, with good muscle tone and a smooth, glossy coat. Masculinity in stallions and femininity in mares are important.
- Penalized: Lack of muscle tone, thinness, obesity, rough coat, overall lack of conditioning

Please email your responses to Saddle Horse Report at

Please send your email in prior to February 18, as we are providing the responses to the American Saddlebred Horse Association prior to their convention.

More Stories

  • Saddlebred Speakeasy-Whoopee!

    It was the berries. Guys and dolls arrived spiffed up to the American Saddlebred Museum’s Saddlebred Speakeasy event at the Golden Ox in Kansas City. The Great Gatsby himself would have loved this event... Read More
  • What Matters? Missions Matter.

    Every effective organization should have a Mission Statement.  It serves as a beacon and a guidebook to help make decisions. If a decision takes an organization in such a direction that it doesn’t serve the Mission, it shouldn’t be done... Read More
  • Susan Fu Remembrance

    Susan Fu passed away in her sleep on Monday, November 4th, at her home at Dragonsmeade in Winchester, Kentucky. She had been battling cancer... Read More
  • Arrangements for Dr. Alan R. Raun

    Visitation with the family of Dr. Alan Raun will be held Sunday November 24th from 4-7pm at O’Leary’s Funeral Home, 1020 Main Street, Norwalk, Iowa. A Celebration Of Life Service will take place the following day, November 25th at 10 am at Norwalk Christian Church located at 701 Main Street in Norwalk. Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 11 19 Morgan Daily

    Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 11 19 Morgan Main

    Read More
  • Statement of AMHA in Response to Bennett Litigation

    You may have learned that one of our members and directors, Vicki Bennett, has filed a lawsuit against current and former AMHA board members. Her complaints are wide-ranging, but focus mostly on the management and operation of the Grand National and World Championship Morgan Horse Show®... Read More
  • Latest Issue 11 11 19

    Read More
  • From the Desk of Marty Schaffel: What We Can Learn From Horses

    I came across the following article and video clip this morning. It shows a horse going into danger to lead other horses to safety. It reminds us of how much a horse cares and what we can learn from them... Read More
  • Obituary – Dale Sloat

    It is with heavy hearts that the Sloat Family would like to announce the passing of Dale Allyn Sloat, 77, on October 30, 2019. Dale is preceded in death by his parents, Lynn and Beatrice Sloat; wife of forty-eight years, Susan Sutton Sloat; and son, Lee Allyn Sloat. He is survived by his son Jeffrey Edwin Sloat, and grandson Dallyn Sloat, both of Shelbyville, KY; and sister, Karolyn (Greg) Donahue of Florida. Read More