Skip to content

More Misleading HSUS Fundraising



reprinted from Humanewatch.org

Editor’s Note:

With competing legislation in Congress relative to the Horse Protection Act, Saddle Horse Report is keenly watching the development of the legislation and its impact on the American Saddlebred and Morgan breeds. While these bills purpose is to stop soring in the Tennessee Walking Horse breed, there are some very sweeping changes to the Horse Protection Act that would in fact apply to all horse breeds within the PAST Act. The American Horse Council strongly encouraged the American Saddlebred Horse Association, American Morgan Horse Association and United Professional Horsemen’s Association to support the PAST Act. At the time, the competing legislation had not been introduced that more specifically targets soring. 

Perhaps the most alarming fact is that the Whitfield bill, called the PAST Act, was proposed by Congressman Ed Whitfield, whose wife works for the Humane Society of the United States. The HSUS has been instrumental in the drafting and promotion of the legislation and has played a key role in the development of the changes in the law.

HumaneWatch.org is an independent watchdog organization, unaffiliated with any horse industry that reports on the irregularities in the HSUS’s behavior based upon their claims in solicitations. We have reprinted the following news release from HumaneWatch.org so that the Saddle Horse Report reader can have the knowledge to look further to determine the facts about the pending legislation and HSUS’s ultimate purpose as it relates to all show horse breeds.



The Humane Society of the United States does not run a single pet shelter and gives only 1 percent of its money to local pet shelters. Despite the common misconceptions among the general public and HSUS's own donors, HSUS claims that its fundraising isn't deceptive. New documents cast doubt on that defense.

The Massachusetts attorney general publishes online contracts between charities and their solicitors or fundraising counsel. It also requires these companies to file forms with information about how much money from a campaign is expected to go to charity, and how much donors are told will go to charity.

There's a disparity in some cases.

Fine Line Communications runs HSUS's in-bound call center for a fee, and tells the Massachusetts attorney general that HSUS will receive 10% of the gross receipts of the money it raises. But then, in the very next line, states that it will tell prospective donors that “approximately 90% will go to the charitable organization.”

 

It doesn't take a math whiz to see that things aren't right. This contract goes through June 2015.

Here's Donor Services Group, which has a contract with Humane Society International (based out of HSUS's office in Washington, D.C.).

 

The charity will receive 2% of the gross receipts, but prospective donors are told that 100% of their donation will go to charity.

That's certainly misleading. It may be technically true that 100% of the proceeds go first to the charity, which then pays the solicitor 98% of the proceeds. But when people ask how much money will go to charity, they mean net gain of the campaign.

And then there's Donor Care Center, raising money for HSUS:

Starting to get the picture?

People who support the Humane Society of the United States think their donation will help cats and dogs. But much of that money never reaches pet shelters or even HSUS, instead winding up in the pockets of for-profit solicitors who use misleading statements. HSUS knows this; it agrees to the contracts.

CharityWatch, an independent watchdog, gives HSUS a “C-minus” grade and finds that up to 45% of HSUS's budget is spent on overhead. But if you asked the HSUS solicitor on the phone, you might not ever learn that.

More Stories

  • Obituary - Rich Robertson

    Saddle Horse Report learned of the passing of noted horse trainer Rich Robertson on December 24, 2017 at the age of 69. Robertson spent several years as the trainer for Susan Phillips’ Alpha-Sun Stables, showing world-class stars across the country. Read More
  • Brookhill's Fame Now Offered For Your Consideration

    The March 12 issue of Saddle Horse Report will feature its Spring Sales Spectacular. In addition to a special rate, one of several extras for placing horses for sale in that issue will be each horse will be featured on the home page of our website like this. This big, handsome, bay gelding has been a proven champion in the Amateur Ladies Three-Gaited, Adult Park and Show Pleasure divisions. If you're looking for a safe, competitive pleasure mount, he is the one. Direct inquires to Mark Utoft. Read More
  • CH Wicked In A Winning Way Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    The March 12 issue of Saddle Horse Report will feature its Spring Sales Spectacular. In addition to a special rate, one of several extras for placing horses for sale in that issue will be each horse will be featured on the home page of our website like this. A World's and Reserve World's Champion, he is enough horse for the amateur or ladies five-gaited division but would be a superstar in the 13 and under or five-gaited pleasure division. Direct inquires to Mark Utoft. Read More
  • AMHA Announces Board of Director Election Results

    The American Morgan Horse Association, Inc., held its annual meeting of members on February 16, 2018 in Lexington, Kentucky.  Read More
  • 2018 AMHA/WMF Stallion Service Auction Results

    Nearly $75,000 was raised at the 2018 AMHA/WMF Stallion Service Auction. The net income following expenses from this auction go to Morgan breed promotion and will be distributed to the World Morgan Futurity, AMHA regional shows, the AMHA Show Grant Program, and AMHA's Marketing and Promotion. Read More
  • Heritage Stables Open House

    Bryan and Katy Earehart announce their first Open House, Saturday February 24 from 9:00 a.m. to 11:00 a.m. at Heritage Stables, 6209 Bethel Church Rd, Gibsonville, North Carolina. Light breakfast items will be available while enjoying Hackney Pony demonstrations and sharing a common love for the Hackney. Read More
  • ASB Museum accepting applications

    The American Saddlebred Museum is seeking a skilled development and marketing professional to assist in fundraising, donor relationships, and execution of marketing and communication strategies for the Museum, located in Lexington, Kentucky at the Kentucky Horse Park.  Read More
  • Latest Issue Feb-19-18

    Read More
  • UPHA Chapter 14 Scholarship Applications Available

    Chapter 14 of the United Professional Horsemen’s Association offers educational scholarships annually with up to $7,500 awarded. These scholarships are open to applicants who are high school seniors or college freshmen. Applicants must be UPHA Chapter 14 Junior or Associate members or the child of an Active UPHA Chapter 14 member. Read More
  • Jubilee Regional Morgan Horse Show Holding Online Fundraiser

    With the commitment to a Bigger and Better Jubilee in 2019, the show committee is not letting time get away. “We have been meeting every week via conference call and have been working on the financial side of the show in the past month, said Jubilee treasurer Kathy Beverage. Read More