Skip to content

More Misleading HSUS Fundraising



reprinted from Humanewatch.org

Editor’s Note:

With competing legislation in Congress relative to the Horse Protection Act, Saddle Horse Report is keenly watching the development of the legislation and its impact on the American Saddlebred and Morgan breeds. While these bills purpose is to stop soring in the Tennessee Walking Horse breed, there are some very sweeping changes to the Horse Protection Act that would in fact apply to all horse breeds within the PAST Act. The American Horse Council strongly encouraged the American Saddlebred Horse Association, American Morgan Horse Association and United Professional Horsemen’s Association to support the PAST Act. At the time, the competing legislation had not been introduced that more specifically targets soring. 

Perhaps the most alarming fact is that the Whitfield bill, called the PAST Act, was proposed by Congressman Ed Whitfield, whose wife works for the Humane Society of the United States. The HSUS has been instrumental in the drafting and promotion of the legislation and has played a key role in the development of the changes in the law.

HumaneWatch.org is an independent watchdog organization, unaffiliated with any horse industry that reports on the irregularities in the HSUS’s behavior based upon their claims in solicitations. We have reprinted the following news release from HumaneWatch.org so that the Saddle Horse Report reader can have the knowledge to look further to determine the facts about the pending legislation and HSUS’s ultimate purpose as it relates to all show horse breeds.



The Humane Society of the United States does not run a single pet shelter and gives only 1 percent of its money to local pet shelters. Despite the common misconceptions among the general public and HSUS's own donors, HSUS claims that its fundraising isn't deceptive. New documents cast doubt on that defense.

The Massachusetts attorney general publishes online contracts between charities and their solicitors or fundraising counsel. It also requires these companies to file forms with information about how much money from a campaign is expected to go to charity, and how much donors are told will go to charity.

There's a disparity in some cases.

Fine Line Communications runs HSUS's in-bound call center for a fee, and tells the Massachusetts attorney general that HSUS will receive 10% of the gross receipts of the money it raises. But then, in the very next line, states that it will tell prospective donors that “approximately 90% will go to the charitable organization.”

 

It doesn't take a math whiz to see that things aren't right. This contract goes through June 2015.

Here's Donor Services Group, which has a contract with Humane Society International (based out of HSUS's office in Washington, D.C.).

 

The charity will receive 2% of the gross receipts, but prospective donors are told that 100% of their donation will go to charity.

That's certainly misleading. It may be technically true that 100% of the proceeds go first to the charity, which then pays the solicitor 98% of the proceeds. But when people ask how much money will go to charity, they mean net gain of the campaign.

And then there's Donor Care Center, raising money for HSUS:

Starting to get the picture?

People who support the Humane Society of the United States think their donation will help cats and dogs. But much of that money never reaches pet shelters or even HSUS, instead winding up in the pockets of for-profit solicitors who use misleading statements. HSUS knows this; it agrees to the contracts.

CharityWatch, an independent watchdog, gives HSUS a “C-minus” grade and finds that up to 45% of HSUS's budget is spent on overhead. But if you asked the HSUS solicitor on the phone, you might not ever learn that.

More Stories

  • REPORT Leaderboard

    Saddle Horse Report is pleased to present the New REPORT Leaderboard winners which tabulates the leading trainers and sires, both within the American Saddlebred and Hackney Pony classes, at the 2017 World's Championship Horse Show through the end of classes on Sunday, August 20. Read More
  • Sunday Matinee Highlights From WCHS

                The second session of the 2017 World’s Championship Horse Show got underway at noon on Sunday with 15 classes, namely four splits of the Adult Show Pleasure class, older age group equitation classes, open park qualifiers, amateur road pony and horse classes, gaited ponies and an amateur gentlemen’s long-tail class. Read More
  • Honor Society

    Kathy Humphries and Honor Society were reserve in Sunday afternoon’s Amateur Junior Hackney Pleasure Driving Pony class. Longtime friend and trainer Myra Williams worked it out for them to become a team and move to Majestic Oaks to pursue Kathy’s dream of showing her pony at Louisville under the Campbell’s direction. Read More
  • Instant Connection

    A last minute substitution turned out great for Jordyn Isgrigg and Reedann's Fantastic Design. Read More
  • Opening Night At The World's Championship Horse Show

            The 114th World’s Championship Horse Show got underway Saturday night, August 19 with 89 teams competing in the opening session. As tradition dictates it was County Fair night with seven championships held. Rich and Maureen Campbell’s Majestic Oaks won all three pony classes with Maureen driving Regal’s Norma Jean LF, Regal’s Prime Rate LF and Heartland Infinity to the roses. Read More
  • Latest Issue Aug 21 17

    Read More
  • AMHA Regional Shows to Continue

    The AMHA Board of Directors voted at its August 12 third quarter meeting to continue the Regional Show Program with changes to its criteria beginning with the 2018 show season... Read More
  • 2017 Land Of Lincoln Purebred Livestock Breeder’s Award – Paul Briney

    Paul Briney of Chatham, Illinois, has ben a strong advocate for purebred equine in the State of Illinois for over 50 years. He was instrumental in the development of the Horsemen’s Council of Illinois (HCI) established in 1982... Read More
  • Portrait of Dabora Founder

    A portrait of David L. Howard, founder of Saddle Horse Report, was hung today at the Dabora offices in Shelbyville, Tenn., to honor his memory. Howard passed away unexpectedly in December of 2016... Read More
  • Louisiana Fall Festival Horse Show Announces Improvements, Officials

    The 2017 edition of the Louisiana Fall Festival Horse Show will have new dates and improved stalls, Show Manager Tommy Benton announced. The show will be held Oct. 6 - 8 at the historic John M. Parker Coliseum on the Louisiana State University campus in Baton Rouge... Read More