Skip to content

Letter To The Editor From Scarlett Mattson


To the Editor:


The proposed two-year-old three-gaited natural tail class split at Ky State Fair has created far more heated discussion than I ever would have imagined. Since I am in the middle of this controversy I would like to clarify some things concerning me that have been rumored.


Number 1 - That I came up with the idea of this class. Sorry but I didn't.


Number 2 - There was a tie vote of 4-4 in the advisory committee, and I broke the tie. Sorry about that too, but we do not vote in the advisory committee. They recommend things and if the recommendations will be beneficial to the exhibitor, trainer, and/or show and can be implemented it is done.


The concept for this class was presented to me in November before I left on vacation to Africa. Needless to say it was on my mind the entire time I was there. When I returned I knew what I was going to do. I then met with someone who I have the highest regard, admiration, and respect for, who is not in the horse business, but runs one of the most complex situations in the state and does it better than anyone I know. What he said to me made me look at the situation entirely differently. He told me I had to take my feelings and thoughts out of the equation and look at the big picture.


The Association thought this would help the breed and something needed to be done to help it. The Association only wanted two years to try this at the Ky State Fair. This isn't a very long time, and if you don't try something you will never know if it will work. In two years the split of this class will be reevaluated and acted upon accordingly.


I consider it an honor, privilege, and mostly a surprise to be manager of the World's Championship Horse Show. Those who know me know that I try to be fair and honest with everyone - exhibitor, trainer, groom, or spectator. I try to look at the whole picture and the effect it will have on all concerned before I make a decision for this horse show or any horse show I manage. I knew I was in a no-win situation with this decision no matter what I chose, but I felt that the Association should be given at least two years to try it. Whether it works remains to be seen.


The specs for this split are being drawn up and will be published as soon as they are finalized. I have had Saddlebreds all my life and have been going to the Ky State Fair before most of you knew what it was. I can safely say I care as much or more about the Saddlebred than anyone, and I have seen them decrease in popularity. I have my thoughts as to why, but am not going into that, but if having the split of this class will help I will give it the chance to be done.

Scarlett Mattson


More Stories

  • **Updated Event Cancellations

    Saddle Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse events. Read More
  • A Blast From The Past

    Saddle Horse Report is pleased to bring you a series of past feature stories on some of the greats of our sport. Please enjoy this walk down memory lane. Read More
  • Future Forum: The Up and Coming of Young Trainers

    Enjoy the first in a series on young trainers! Read More
  • Foals N Focus – Week Nine

    In this, our next to last week of the #foalsNfocus photo contest, the bar was really raised with several quality shots submitted. Once again, the “hope” of foals is what many in this country need with so much unrest... Read More
  • Dr. Scott Bennett Remembered

    Thursday, June 4th is a sad day in the American Saddlebred/Hackney/Morgan show world as Dr. Scott Bennett, a 2017 inductee into the World’s Championship Horse Show Hall of Fame, lost his brave battle with cancer... Read More
  • Class of 2020 Yearbook

    Saddle Horse Report presents the Class of 2020 Yearbook. We are proud to feature some of the 2020 graduates who are and will be a major force in the show horse industry. We know their talent and perseverance will help carry them on to many successes ahead. Read More
  • Time to Nominate

    Do you know a UPHA member that should be acknowledged not only for their success in the show ring but also their contributions to UPHA and our industry? Nominate them for the 2020 UPHA Hall of Fame and Lifetime Achievement awards by June 15, 2020. Read More
  • From the Desk of Marty Schaffel: Data Points Are Telling

    When I get ready to leave the house for the day, I am checking the data points regarding the weather before I leave so I know what I need for the day.  Those data points are: What is the temperature? Is it raining or going to rain? Is there a strong wind? Is it humid? And so on.   Read More
  • Summer Dreams Reopens Show Season

    Katy Texas was the site of the first show back in business after the pandemic brought a sudden halt to all normal activities, including horse shows. May Chadick and her team at Vantage Point Stables did a great job of providing exhibitors a chance at normalcy with all of the safety protocols in place.  Read More
  • Ten Years Ago - Connecticut Morgan

    Plans for the 60th anniversary of the Connecticut Morgan Horse Show are on hold until next year. While we miss being there this week, let’s take a look back at some of the highlights from the 50th anniversary in 2010. Read More