Skip to content

Letter to the Editor - Joan Hamilton

Dear Chairpersons,

Thank you for your response.

Your letter dated February 6, 2004, offers much insight into the history of the “Munford Rule” change, but little to explain why you chose to force this issue to a vote before it could be discussed and presented in an open forum at the ASHA Convention, then voted on by their board of directors.

In an organized fashion the “Munford Rule” change proposal was moved to the open forum at the UPHA Convention, then moved onto its board of directors. It is my observation that you did not move this rule change proposal to the open forum at the ASHA Convention and its board of directors, even though you had received notice that this had not been done. Clearly you were aware ASHA was interested in and affected by this rule.

By your actions, you denied ASHA members the opportunity to express their opinions, ideas and concerns. In addition, you missed an opportunity to gather information which could contribute solutions to many of the problems you are addressing. What disadvantage is there in letting these proposals be presented in an open forum at the ASHA Convention? If this rule change would have moved onto the open forum at the ASHA Convention it would have had the potential to reach its final destination, the USEF Board of Directors, one year later. If it is good enough to be adopted in 2004, it should be good enough in 2005.

As you pointed out, your committee is charged with the responsibility and the right to make decisions regarding the rules of competition. I have not suggested that you violated any rules under which your U.S. Equestrian Saddlebred Committee must conduct itself. I am suggesting that it is unwise, unfair and unacceptable to exclude the ASHA members and its board of directors from the rule making and changing process. In your honest attempt to work through difficult and controversial issues you did not treat ASHA with the same respect you showed UPHA. I am encouraged that you now recognize the strong interest that ASHA has shown and I hope you will present new rules and rule changes to ASHA as you do with UPHA.

I look forward to a more constructive approach to solving problems in the future.


Joan A. Hamilton

More Stories

  • **Updated Event Cancellations

    Saddle Horse Report will provide daily updates to the list of canceled and postponed horse events. Read More
  • A Blast From The Past

    Saddle Horse Report is pleased to bring you a series of past feature stories on some of the greats of our sport. Please enjoy this walk down memory lane. Read More
  • UPHA Maria Knight Memorial Scholarship; Up to $10,000 Offered

    The UPHA Maria Knight Scholarship was established to honor UPHA Professional, Maria Knight and her commitment to providing a college education for her daughter... Read More
  • From the Desk of Marty Schaffel: Acts of Courage

    I was never prouder to be a member of our association than when I saw the statement that was signed by so many of our members. Clearly, these are difficult times. Tough decisions have to be made. What is reassuring to me is that people are making those decisions and are acting with courage. Read More
  • American Saddlebred Museum Launches Educational Resources & Movie Club

    The American Saddlebred Museum has added online resources and educational offerings to its website. These resources include reading lists, activity sheets, coloring pages and writing prompts. Resources range from fun activities to true educational resources for educators. New activities will be added regularly to keep the page fresh and young minds active!   Read More
  • A Letter To UPHA Membership

    I hope this email finds you healthy and safe. These are frightening times for all. Our membership is unique: We are not just working to keep our families and staff safe; we are also tasked with providing the highest level of care for our horses and ponies. Read More
  • American Saddlebred Museum – April 2020

    The Museum's first Movie Club meeting was a big success! Don't miss our next installment on April 11 at 3:00 p.m. EST when we will discuss Secretariat! Wondering how it works? The concept is similar to a book club, but you watch a movie instead of reading a book. Read More
  • Foals N Focus – Week 2

    Again, one of the most enjoyable parts of this past week was reviewing all the #foalsNfocus pictures that were submitted.Foals mean hope and the future and we all need that right now... Read More
  • Serving America in a Time of Need

    We are pleased to share the following article on American Saddlebred/Hackney owner/exhibitor Jeoff Bodenhorst and the good works his company is doing during this pandemic... Read More
  • UPHA Classic Nomination Discount Extended to June 1

    The UPHA Board of Directors has voted to extend the discounted rate for Classic Nominations from April 1 to June 1 due to the COVID-19 Pandemic. The $100 eligibility fee will be accepted with a postmark on or before June 1, 2020. After June 1, the eligibility fee becomes $150 per nomination. Read More