Skip to content

Equine Death - Sheriff Gaines

Sheriff Gaines was foaled on May 5, 2002, and originally was named The Champagne Pirate. He was a big bold flashy chestnut with a white blaze and four white stockings, sired by Champagne Fizz and out of Shamrock's China Moon. He was later renamed Sheriff Gaines in honor of his former trainer's best friend, Sheriff Jerry "Peanuts" Gaines of Bowling Green, Ky. In May 2008, the horse suffered a ruptured cranial cruciate ligament, detached meniscus and severely damaged cartilage in his left stifle joint, all of which were permanent injuries that brought his show career to an end. Despite efforts to rehabilitate him to at least pasture soundness, his condition further deteriorated and he had to be euthanized on Sept. 1, 2009.

In his short life, Sheriff Gaines had an amazing and very promising show career. In 2005, as a three-year-old, he placed third out of nine in the Five-Gaited Three-Year-Old Stallion/Gelding class at the World's Championship Horse Show in Louisville. Later that same year, Sheriff Gaines won the UPHA Five-Gaited Classic at the St. Louis National Charity Show and was the UPHA Five-Gaited Reserve Champion at the American Royal in Kansas City, Mo.

His success continued into 2006. He was the Novice Five-Gaited Champion at the Pro Am Benefit Show in Georgia and the Junior Five-Gaited Reserve Champion at the Indianapolis Charity Horse Show. He "wowed" the crowd at the Mercer County Fair in Harrodsburg, Ky., where he was the Junior Five-Gaited Champion before winning a reserve world's championship title at Louisville in the Junior Five-Gaited Stallion/Gelding division.
His owners, Allison and Betty Pullin, considered themselves very fortunate to have had the opportunity to obtain this wonderful show horse in December 2006. Allison earned several nice ribbons showing him at the West Virginia State Fair and ASHAV in 2007, and at the Raleigh Spring Premier in 2008. Allison was looking forward to showing Sheriff Gaines at Lexington Junior League and Louisville in the junior exhibitor five-gaited division in 2008 until those hopes were dashed by his devastating leg injury.

Sheriff Gaines will always be remembered as the big, flashy chestnut gelding with the white blaze and four white stockings whose gameness gave him so much promise for the show ring. He was more than a show horse to the Pullins. He was a member of their family and will be loved and deeply missed for many years to come.
The Pullin family would like to thank Dr. William Baker, DVM of Woodford Equine Hospital, Versailles, Ky., and Dr. Christie Boyd DVM of Wytheville, Va., for their expertise in diagnosing and subsequent treatment of Sheriff Gaines’s injury; to James and Lisa Lawrence of Coventry Woods Stable, Charleston, W.Va., for taking Sheriff Gaines into their barn and caring for him and providing him a place to attempt rehabilitation during this past year, and for their constant faith and support; and especially to Sheriff Jerry "Peanuts" Gaines, the horse’s namesake, of Bowling Green, Ky., for his never-ending support, hope and faith that the horse would return to the show ring.

Anyone wanting or needing more information on this rare but devastating leg injury, please contact owner Betty Pullin at (304) 744-6094.

More Stories

  • ASHA Seeks Executive Director

    The American Saddlebred Horse Assocation (ASHA) is currently seeking to hire its next Executive Director. Founded in 1871, the ASHA’s mission is to safeguard the integrity of the American Saddlebred breed, to promote the use of American Saddlebreds, and to expand the public knowledge of the American Saddlebred.  Read More
  • Prize Lists Available for Asheville Saddlebred Classic

    The inaugural Asheville Saddlebred Classic is fast approaching and prize lists are now available at The entries closing date is April 20th and entries can be submitted online until that date. Hard copies of the prize list are available upon request... Read More
  • Blue Ribbon Opening

    Read More
  • Royal Crest's Mister Stone Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    Consistently in the ribbons, this wonderful gelding has proven to be an absolute star in whatever division he is entered in: Walk and Trot Equitation, Open English Pleasure, Junior Exhibitor Country Pleasure - he can do it all and he is ready for his next young rider! Direct inquires to Country Meadow Farm. Read More
  • HS Queen Of The Castle Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    A lovely mare that will get you noticed! Shown successfully in Junior Exhibitor and Adult Show Pleasure and Park Pleasure with lots of wins to her credit. She is suitable for a more advanced rider - let her win for you! Direct Inquiries to Jennifer Dixon. Read More
  • VVM Uncensored Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    This cute gelding has plenty of expression and is suitable for any level rider. “Vegas” has been shown successfully in the Classic Pleasure and English Pleasure divisions. Have some fun with him in the show ring! Direct Inquiries to Jennifer Dixon. Read More
  • Supreme Kiss Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    This beautiful bay gelding turns heads when he’s in the show ring! Successfully shown in the five-gaited pleasure division and will walk all day long. Kiss is ready for his next rider! Direct Inquiries to Jennifer Dixon. Read More
  • Sedgefield’s IL Divo Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    This colorful 7-year-old gelding is a blast to ride! He has been successfully shown in pleasure, park pleasure and park. He is ideal for a junior exhibitor or amateur rider. Started on pattern work, he would be a top contender in the equitation division as well.  He has a great attitude and loads of personality. Don’t miss the chance to own a great one! Direct inquires to Country Meadow Farm. Read More
  • Mr. McDreamy Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    A superstar on the competitive Country Pleasure division and is also equitated. A perfect first horse, he is high-headed, safe and loves his job. Priced to sell. Direct inquires to Evan and Mary Orr. Read More
  • Lady Cinnamint Now Being Offered For Your Consideration

    Proven in the competitive Country Pleasure and Show Pleasure divisions. Very reasonably priced and ready for any level rider. Direct inquires to Evan and Mary Orr. Read More