Skip to content

Dogs kill Prized Shelby County Show Pony

SHELBY COUNTY, Ky. —The horse community in Shelby County is in shock tonight after a prized pony used to teach dozens of children to ride was killed by two pit bulls.

Click Here for news video posted on

Residents in the tight-knit horse community in Shelbyville and Simpsonville contacted WLKY after the death of a popular show pony at Premier Stables.

According to the investigation, it appears two pit bulls mauled the pony to death.

"She raised them from pups. They've never been raised to fight or be mean," said George Tapp, the father of the dogs' owner. "They're good-natured dogs. There's no meanness in them at all."

Investigators said the dogs turned violent Friday evening.

The two pit bulls managed to get out of their cages and run next door to Premier Saddlebred Riding Stables, owned by Sarah and Rob Byers, one of the top names in the saddlebred industry.

They killed a barn cat and then focused on a well-known show pony.

"It shocked me, and how it happened and how they could've gotten into the barn," Tapp said.

Crystal Tapp, the owner of the dogs, declined comment at the advice of her attorney.

The Tapp family has owned the property next door for years.

George Tapp said the dogs never gave any indication of aggression toward horses. He has 18 horses on the property.

"We got some horses that a neighbor keeps over here and they've never bothered any of them. Nothing," Tapp said.

Parents who contacted WLKY said dozens of children learned to ride on the female pony, saying she was a superstar in their eyes.

The two pit bulls are being held in quarantine at the Shelby County Animal Shelter and it's their lives that are now in question.

At the advice of their attorney, the Byers also declined comment. The Tapp family said this is a horrible situation for all involved.

"Well sure I feel bad about it. I love animals," George Tapp said.

For those in the community who enjoy riding lessons at Premier Stables so much, they hope that the Byers family will be OK to continue.

As far as the Tapp family is concerned, they hope that their business with the Byers family will continue as well and they hope this issue can be resolved.

The Shelby County Animal Shelter remains closed until Tuesday.

It's still uncertain as to what will happen to the two quarantined pit bulls and who will make the final decision.

 Reposted from


More Stories

  • #FoalsNFocus – Week 11

    Some are just taking their first steps, others are shedding, but the quality of the 2023 foal crop has been spectacular week after week in all of our show breeds. Read More
  • High Spirits Riders Make Horses a Way of Life

    “The journeys for all five of these kids are basically the same. They’ve all become barn rats and it started with lessons and Academy,” said High Spirits Farm instructor Allison Cantrell, referring to the five junior exhibitor riders who just participated at the Madison Classic. “Four of these kids first showed with us and they are riding horses that were bred here. Read More
  • Beth Jones Passes Away

    Saddle Horse Report has learned the sad news of the passing of longtime owner and exhibitor Beth Jones of Bellefontaine, Ohio Monday, June 5th. Read More
  • ASHBA Announces Hunter Task Force

    The Hunter Country Pleasure division is one of the fastest-growing American Saddlebred divisions, with 645 classes across the nation in 2022. ASHBA recognizes the importance of this division and the versatility it offers our breed. Read More
  • Attention Hackney Youth

    The AHHS announced Hackney Youth Creative Arts and Writing Contest. This is your opportunity to showcase your creativity. Your goal is to share YOUR representation of the Hackney using any medium (material) of your choosing. Three lucky winners will be drawn from the entries to receive $500 each, along with select entries receiving featured spots in the youth newsletter. Read More
  • Latest Issue 6 5 23

    Read More
  • Hoof Beats and High Fashion

    The American Saddlebred Museum presents the annual July Fundraiser—Hoof Beats and High Fashion on Friday, July 14 at 11:00 a.m.  Read More
  • Freedman’s Gift Package Raffle

    The American Saddlebred Museum and Freedman's are offering a chance to win an amazing gift package and support the Museum at the same time! The prize package, valued at $550, is full of useful items any horseperson needs and features several exciting new products as well. Read More
  • Latest Issue 6 23 HW

    Read More
  • #FoalsNFocus – Week 10

    While horse shows are stacked one on top of another, the 2023 foal crop is also blossoming across the country. Submitted by owner/breeder Kristen Wells, this week’s winning photo is of her May 20th colt by Noble Braveheart out of Hannah Starlight, a daughter of reserve world’s champion Leatherwood’s Starlight. Read More